I wet myself a little when reading Hillary Clinton’s opinions on internet freedom and allowed myself a little gloat in the direction of our very own Minister for Botching Everything he Touches, Senator Conroy.
Her speech contains some of the most rational and future-proofed analysis of the internet in its global political context ever published. Conroy’s response, however, is hackneyed, uninformative and fails, in every sense, to engage Clinton’s arguments. I’ll attempt to illustrate this disjunction without flooding the page with quotes, but Hillary’s words are too erudite and well constructed for me to paraphrase too often.
Clinton launches the thrust of her speech by quoting Obama’s warning to China,
the more freely information flows, the stronger societies become.
Even Conroy can’t disagree, saying that
The Rudd Government agrees with Secretary Clinton that the internet can transform societies and enable and empower individuals to engage, connect and have a greater impact than they ever have
So while Conroy nods his head and mumbles along in fluent pollie-speak, Clinton begins pushing the concept further, condemning Governments’ use of censorship.
technologies with the potential to open up access to government and promote transparency can also be hijacked by governments to crush dissent and deny human rights… [As] history itself has already condemned these tactics.
Conroy by now is slowing his vigorous head-nodding as he realises he’s on the wrong side of the fence. Just in time, however, Clinton throws him a line:
Now, all societies recognize that free expression has its limits. We do not tolerate those who incite others to violence, such as the agents of al-Qaida who are, at this moment, using the internet to promote the mass murder of innocent people across the world. And hate speech that targets individuals on the basis of their race, religion, ethnicity, gender, or sexual orientation is reprehensible. It is an unfortunate fact that these issues are both growing challenges that the international community must confront together. And we must also grapple with the issue of anonymous speech. Those who use the internet to recruit terrorists or distribute stolen intellectual property cannot divorce their online actions from their real world identities.
Our Minister for Broadband Hindrance and the Digital Expolitation of Children sighs in relief, he’s said the exact same thing!
Australians have always recognised that there is some content which is not acceptable in any civilised society. [So we're going to censor the internet]
Unfortunately for Senator Steve, the line Clinton threw him came complete with bait and hook:
But these challenges must not become an excuse for governments to systematically violate the rights and privacy of those who use the internet for peaceful political purposes.
But Conroy’s not trying to violate our rights, right? Right? Hillary?
Some countries have erected electronic barriers that prevent their people from accessing portions of the world’s networks. They’ve expunged words, names, and phrases from search engine results. They have violated the privacy of citizens who engage in non-violent political speech. These actions contravene the Universal Declaration on Human Rights,
At this point our friend in the Senate should be rethinking his policy’s impact on diplomatic ties with the US. Hell, even Google thinks the plan is a disaster. Unfortunately, even the most powerful woman in the world can’t persuade the least receptive man in the world. In the very same press release as his insubstantial agreement with Clinton, he goes on to plug his censorship plans as a good thing. So Australians are in the hole now right? Wrong.
We are also supporting the development of new tools that enable citizens to exercise their rights of free expression by circumventing politically motivated censorship.
Thank you Hillary, thank you. Now if you could just leave the installation materials for TOR on my doorstep I’ll be able to circumvent Con-job Conroy’s censorship machine.
Tune in next time for how the anti-censorship campaign needs to move forward to beat this once and for all.
*Edit: Fixed the first link to Clinton’s speech.






